Police Statements from 1960 Murder Case Show Conflicting Details

Posted: Updated:

EDINBURG – Testimony continues in the Irene Garza murder trial.

On Monday, McAllen Police Chief Victor Rodriguez took the stand. His department reopened the case in 2002.

Rodriguez read John Feit’s police statement to the jury, paragraph by paragraph.

The former priest had been assigned to Sacred Heart Church in McAllen to help with Holy Week services in 1960.

On May 3 of that year, Feit told police that on Holy Saturday, April 16, he was walking out of the rectory but went back inside to answer the phone. He said a young woman called asking to speak to someone and insisted it was important to talk to a priest, according to the document.

Rodriguez said Feit told police he waited for the woman to arrive at the rectory.

“The dots are connecting to him. That is, Irene Garza having been with him," said Rodriguez. "The parents knowing she had been with him, and now that she’s missing, these things are getting very hot for him. So, he’s not basically concerned about the fact that this is coming down on him."

The report states Feit claimed she wanted to meet privately in the rectory, not in confessional because she didn’t want others to hear her confession. It states after speaking with Garza, Feit sent her back to the church and assured her that no one would hear the confession.

The chief also read a second statement, dated June 14, 1960, which conflicts with the initial statement he gave police. In it, it states he took her to confession in the rectory that day.

Jurors are currently on lunch break and will be taken back to the courtroom to continue the trial. 

Para leer noticias en español, visite nuestra sección Español.
  • Stories

    • Sunday, officers responded to a home on the 1200 block of Calle Milpa on a call that the girl was found unresponsive in an inflatable pool.

    • (Gaston County Sheriff's Office via AP). This Sunday, May 20, 2018, booking photo provided by the Gaston County Sheriff's Office shows Roger Self. Police say that Self intentionally rammed a vehicle into a restaurant shortly after midday Sunday, May 20...

      Man faces murder charges in restaurant crash that killed kin

      Authorities say man intentionally rammed vehicle into a North Carolina restaurant busy with weekend lunch crowd, killing his daughter, another person and injuring several others.
    • Impacts of Artificial Reef on Red Snapper Fishing Season

      Federal Red Snapper fishing season is set to begin June 1st.

      It's projected to be 40 days longer this year than last year.

    • The suspects are considered armed and dangerous.

    • Authorities are investigating the death of a youth in custody at the Evins Regional Juvenile Center in Edinburg.