x

Federal judge dismisses Donna family’s lawsuit over ICE home raid

Federal judge dismisses Donna family’s lawsuit over ICE home raid
16 minutes 10 seconds ago Saturday, November 21 2026 Nov 21, 2026 November 21, 2026 12:49 PM November 21, 2026 in News - Local
Source: KRGV

MCALLEN, Texas (KRGV) — A federal judge in McAllen dismissed a Donna family’s lawsuit over a U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement raid at their home.

In an order signed Nov. 9, U.S. District Judge Randy Crane granted the federal government’s motion to dismiss the case, saying the family lacked standing to pursue the lawsuit.

The lawsuit was filed Feb. 18 in federal court and accused ICE officers of entering the family’s home on Jan. 9 using an administrative warrant, which is not signed by judges.

As previously reported, a video obtained by Channel 5 News shows ICE agents jumping a fence into the family's yard that same day at around 7 a.m.

Video captures Donna family's detainment by alleged federal agents

According to the lawsuit, Humberto Garcia claims he saw trucks outside the home he shares with his three sisters, Andrea, Anna, and a minor identified as L.G., as well as their parents.

The parents are noncitizens but were in the process of obtaining lawful permanent resident status, according to the lawsuit.

Humberto was about to leave for work when he saw ICE agents jump the fence surrounding his home.

The lawsuit said ICE agents pointed their guns at Humberto and attacked him without speaking or identifying themselves. Officers knocked Humberto to the ground, scratched his face, and "several agents had their feet on his back."

The lawsuit claims an officer kicked Andrea's feet, causing her to fall. ICE officers began yelling at her and asking for her father. At this point Andrea asked to see a warrant, but ICE officers did not produce or show one.

ICE officers then accosted Anna, who was bruised from being tightly gripped by agents, according to the lawsuit.

L.G. was asleep inside the home when the raid happened. The lawsuit said she is disabled and suffers from a medical condition that "makes her bones break easily."

L.G. was awakened by officers banging on the windows of the home, according to the lawsuit. Officers then pointed guns at L.G. and "forced her to kneel and raise her hands."

The lawsuit said ICE agents gave the family two minutes to come outside, or they would break down the door. The mother complied and ICE agents entered the home without the family's consent to retrieve the father. The mother was later deported to Mexico.

The government moved to dismiss the case on Sept. 3, arguing the family could not sue on behalf of noncitizens, lacked standing because the claimed injury was too speculative, and had failed to state a claim.

Crane, a Bush-appointed judge, did not rule on whether the ICE agents had permission to enter the property, but agreed with the federal government and said the court did not need to decide the claim-by-claim constitutional arguments because the standing issue controlled the case.

In the filing, Crane wrote that the family had not shown a real and immediate threat of future injury and that past exposure to allegedly illegal conduct was not enough, by itself, to support injunctive relief.

Crane cited Supreme Court precedent in finding the family was seeking forward-looking relief without showing the threat of future harm was certainly impending.

The case was dismissed without prejudice.

More News

Radar
7 Days